Aquaponics Nutrient Recycling Boost Crop Yields Naturally

1.4K

Aquaponics, the integration of fish farming (aquaculture) and soil-free plant cultivation (hydroponics), offers a sustainable solution for food production by recycling fish waste into plant nutrients. Aquaculture refers to raising fish in controlled environments, while hydroponics involves growing plants without soil, using nutrient-rich water.

Together, these systems create a closed-loop ecosystem where fish waste nourishes plants, and plants purify water for fish. However, a significant challenge has limited its efficiency: not all nutrients in fish waste are easily accessible to plants. Fish waste comes in two forms:

1. Dissolved nutrients (like ammonia and nitrate) that plants can absorb directly.
2. Solid waste (sludge) containing organic matter and minerals bound to particles.

While dissolved nutrients like ammonia (NH₃) and nitrate (NO₃⁻) are readily absorbed, up to 50% of essential nutrients remain trapped in solid sludge, which is often discarded. A groundbreaking 2021 study published in Frontiers in Plant Science tackled this issue by developing a novel system to convert fish sludge into a nutrient-rich liquid fertilizer.

The Challenge of Nutrient Management in Aquaponics

In traditional aquaponics systems, fish waste is processed through biofilters—devices that convert toxic ammonia (NH₃) from fish waste into nitrate (NO₃⁻), a form of nitrogen plants can use.

Ammonia is harmful to fish even at low concentrations, while nitrate is a safer nitrogen source for plants. However, solid waste—comprising uneaten feed, fish feces, and microbial biomass—is typically removed and discarded.

This sludge contains valuable nutrients like phosphorus (P), iron (Fe), and micronutrients such as zinc (Zn) and copper (Cu).

Unfortunately, its high organic carbon content makes it unsuitable for direct use in hydroponics. Organic carbon refers to carbon-based molecules from living organisms, which can fuel microbial growth and deplete oxygen in water, harming plant roots. Untreated sludge can clog irrigation systems, promote harmful bacterial growth, and lead to nutrient imbalances in plants.

To address this, researchers from the University of Gothenburg and INRAe-PEIMA France designed a low-cost treatment system inspired by techniques used in wastewater management. Their goal was to unlock nutrients trapped in solid waste while reducing carbon and nitrogen loads that could harm plant growth.

Designing the Aquaponics Experiment: From Fish Tanks to Lettuce Beds

The research team tested four nutrient sources on lettuce (Lactuca sativa) grown in nutrient film technique (NFT) gutters, a common hydroponic setup where a thin film of nutrient-rich water flows over plant roots. The nutrient sources included:

1. Commercial Hydroponic Solution (HNS): A standard mix rich in nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and potassium (K)—the primary macronutrients plants need.
2. Biofilter Effluent (BF): Water from a traditional aquaponic system containing dissolved nutrients after ammonia conversion.
3. Remineralized Effluent (RM): Liquid fertilizer produced by treating fish sludge to release bound nutrients.
4. Combined RM + BF: A blend of remineralized effluent and biofilter water to balance nutrient availability.

Rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) were raised in three recirculating aquaculture systems (RAS)—closed-loop systems where water is continuously filtered and reused. Solid waste from the fish tanks was directed to a three-step treatment system:

1. Settling Basin: A tank where solids settle at the bottom, separating from water.
2. Anaerobic Fermenter: A sealed chamber where microbes break down organic matter without oxygen (anaerobic digestion), producing biogas and reducing sludge volume.
3. Sequential Batch Reactor (SBR): A treatment tank that alternates between oxygen-rich (aerobic) and oxygen-free (anaerobic) phases to encourage nutrient release.

The SBR operated on a 16-hour cycle, mimicking enhanced biological phosphorus removal (EBPR)—a wastewater treatment method where specific bacteria absorb and release phosphorus. During aerobic phases, microbes stored phosphorus internally; during anaerobic phases, they released it into the water. This process transformed sludge into a liquid fertilizer rich in soluble phosphorus and micronutrients.

Lettuce seedlings were grown for eight weeks in a greenhouse with temperature controls (15–25°C). Nutrient solutions were regularly tested for pH (a measure of acidity/alkalinity), electrical conductivity (EC) (indicating nutrient concentration), and levels of key elements like nitrogen, phosphorus, and iron.

At harvest, researchers measured plant biomass, root length, and nutrient levels in leaves and roots using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS)—a technique that detects trace metals and isotopes with high precision.

Nutrient-Rich Fertilizer Boosts Plant Health

The treatment system achieved remarkable results in processing fish sludge. It reduced total suspended solids (TSS)—particles floating in water—by 87.27% ± 9.95, significantly lowering the risk of clogging in hydroponic systems.

Additionally, chemical oxygen demand (COD)—a measure of organic carbon content—dropped by 12-fold, minimizing the potential for harmful microbial growth. The system also released critical nutrients.

Soluble phosphorus levels in the effluent increased by 30% compared to raw sludge, while iron concentrations in the anaerobic fermenter reached 0.83 mg/L.

Although iron levels decreased in the final effluent, the treated sludge provided a balanced mix of micronutrients like copper and zinc, which are often lacking in traditional aquaponics.

Furthermore, plants grown with the commercial hydroponic solution (HNS) had the highest yields, weighing 2–3 times more than those in aquaponic treatments. However, these plants showed unexpected nutrient deficiencies. Young leaves lacked sufficient magnesium (Mg < 100 ppm), calcium (Ca), sodium (Na), and silicon (Si).

Despite containing 460 times more iron than other treatments—thanks to EDTA-chelated iron added to the solution—HNS plants did not have higher iron levels in their leaves. Chelation refers to binding metal ions (like iron) to organic molecules (EDTA) to prevent precipitation and improve solubility.

In contrast, lettuce fertilized with remineralized effluent (RM) had balanced mineral profiles. For example, young leaves contained 2.8% calcium by dry weight, compared to 1.5% in HNS plants. RM plants also had higher magnesium and copper levels.

Interestingly, roots of aquaponic plants (RM and BF treatments) accumulated 2.7–4.6 times more iron than HNS roots, suggesting natural systems enhance iron uptake through microbial interactions.

Meanwhile, root systems revealed stark differences. HNS plants had 50% shorter roots and lower root biomass (2.88% dry weight vs. 4.4–4.5% in aquaponic treatments). Weak root development was linked to limited microbial activity in the sterile commercial solution.

Disease patterns further highlighted the drawbacks of synthetic fertilizers. Nearly one-third of HNS plants developed mold before harvest, a problem absent in aquaponic treatments.

Researchers attributed this to silicon deficiency in HNS plants (less than 0.1 ppm in young leaves vs. 0.3 ppm in RM plants). Silicon strengthens cell walls by forming silica phytoliths, microscopic structures that deter pathogens—a benefit missing in the commercial solution.

Further, ANOVA (Analysis of Variance) and Tukey tests—statistical methods to compare group differences—confirmed the findings. Shoot weights differed significantly across all treatments (*p* < 0.05). However, root metrics in RM + BF and BF treatments were statistically similar, indicating that combining remineralized effluent with traditional aquaponic water could offer a balanced approach.

Why Synthetic Fertilizers Fall Short? Role of Microbes in Plant Health

The study revealed critical flaws in relying solely on commercial nutrient solutions. Excess potassium (K) in HNS (9.2 mmol/L vs. 0.1 mmol/L in aquaponics) blocked calcium and magnesium uptake—a phenomenon known as nutrient lockout, where high concentrations of one nutrient inhibit the absorption of others.

Additionally, HNS plants had weaker root systems and less microbial diversity, reducing their ability to absorb nutrients. Micronutrient imbalances further underscored the limitations of synthetic solutions.

HNS lacked aluminum (Al) and silicon (Si), while aquaponic systems provided a broader spectrum of micronutrients like zinc and copper. These elements, though required in tiny amounts, play vital roles in enzyme function and stress resistance. For example, copper is essential for photosynthesis, while zinc supports protein synthesis.

Aquaponic systems fostered a thriving rhizosphere microbiome—the community of bacteria, fungi, and other microbes living near plant roots. These microbes performed several crucial functions:

• Nutrient Solubilization: Converted insoluble nutrients (e.g., iron oxide) into soluble forms (e.g., Fe²⁺) through enzymatic reactions.
• Organic Acid Production: Released acids like citric acid to dissolve minerals like phosphorus, making them plant-available.
• Pathogen Suppression: Outcompeted harmful microbes for resources, reducing disease risk.

Recent research suggests hydroponic plants rely on microbes for 30–40% of nutrient uptake. In sterile commercial solutions, this symbiotic relationship is disrupted, leading to weaker plants and higher susceptibility to stressors like mold.

Sustainable Farming with Aquaponic Fertilizers And Its Challenges

The research highlights two major opportunities for sustainable farming. First, recycling fish sludge into fertilizer closes the nutrient loop, reducing reliance on mined phosphorus—a finite resource critical for global food production.

 The treatment system recovered 44 mg of phosphorus daily from sludge, meeting 15–20% of lettuce’s phosphorus needs. Scaling this technology could reduce reliance on mined phosphorus, a non-renewable resource critical for global food production.

Second, with phosphate reserves dwindling—experts estimate a 50–100 year supply at current rates—recycling nutrients from waste is no longer optional; it’s essential. While HNS plants grew faster, their nutrient profiles were inferior. RM plants had balanced potassium-to-calcium ratios (1.5 vs. 4.9 in HNS), which is linked to better cell structure and stress tolerance.

Higher magnesium (Mg) and copper (Cu) levels in RM plants may also enhance antioxidant production, improving nutritional value. For example, magnesium is a central component of chlorophyll, while copper aids in lignin formation for sturdy stems.

Silicon’s role in disease resistance cannot be overstated. RM plants, with 0.3 ppm silicon in young leaves, had stronger cell walls than HNS plants (less than 0.1 ppm). This finding aligns with studies showing silicon reduces infection rates in crops like rice and wheat by up to 50%.

While promising, the system faces scalability challenges. The pilot system processed 1.85 grams of sludge daily—far less than commercial farms require. Scaling up would need larger reactors, robust piping to prevent clogs from fish scales, and optimized microbial communities. For example, a farm producing 1 ton of fish daily would generate ~100 kg of sludge, requiring a system 500× larger.

All treatments lacked sufficient manganese (Mn), a micronutrient vital for photosynthesis and enzyme activation. Future studies could explore fortifying fish feed with manganese or integrating mineral supplements into the treatment process.

The Raspberry Pi-controlled system cost under $500, but scaling EBPR reactors for large farms may require significant investment. Governments and NGOs could play a role by funding pilot projects or offering subsidies for sustainable technologies.

Conclusion

This study challenges the “more is better” mindset dominating modern agriculture. By prioritizing nutrient bioavailability—the proportion of nutrients plants can absorb—over sheer quantity, farmers can grow healthier, more resilient crops while reducing waste. The sludge treatment system showcased here is more than an aquaponics upgrade; it’s a blueprint for circular agriculture, where waste becomes a resource and ecosystems thrive on diversity.

As climate change and soil degradation threaten global food security, innovations like these remind us that nature holds the best solutions. The future of farming lies not in isolated technologies but in systems that mimic natural cycles, where every component—from fish waste to root microbes—plays a vital role. By embracing these principles, we can build food systems that nourish both people and the planet.